When in the market for a toilet, whether you are remodeling your bathroom or shopping for a new house, you will come across many brands. Examining different brands, including American Standard vs Mansfield toilets, helps you narrow the options until you find the one you like most.
American Standard produces impressively durable well designed toilets that are also high performing. On the other hand, Mansfield craft toilets that aren’t susceptible to clogging hence low maintenance. Furthermore, Mansfield toilets are flush well and more affordable.
Exploring these toilets’ strengths, weaknesses, and features helps determine the better one.
American Standard Vs Mansfield Toilets Compared
Here’s a comparison table between American Standard and Mansfield toilets:
| Aspect | American Standard Toilets | Mansfield Toilets | |
| 1. | Flush Technology | Offers a variety of flushing systems, including VorMax and FloWise | Uses Pressure-Assist and Gravity Flush technologies |
| 2. | Water Efficiency | Offers WaterSense-certified toilets with low-flow options | Provides low-flow and water-efficient models |
| 3. | Ease of Cleaning | Some models feature EverClean surfaces for easy cleaning | It depends on the specific model, but generally easy to clean |
| 4. | Design Options | Wide range of designs and styles to choose from | Offers a variety of designs |
| 5. | Price Range | Moderate to high price range | An average price range with some affordable options |
| 6. | Durability | Known for producing durable and long-lasting toilets | Generally reliable and durable |
| 7. | Warranty | Offers varying warranty periods depending on the model | Provides warranties for their toilets which vary based on the model |
| 8. | Popularity | A well-established brand with a large customer base | An established brand with a dedicated following |
1. Flushing Mechanism
Both American Standard and Mansfield offer toilets with efficient and effective flushing mechanisms. However, they differ in some aspects.
American Standard is known for its powerful and efficient flushing systems. For instance, its VorMax and Cadet Flushing Systems have received positive reviews for their performance in clearing waste effectively using less water.
The VorMax system, with its jetted scrubbing action, provides thorough bowl cleaning with each flush.
On the other hand, Mansfield toilets often incorporate a flush tower mechanism and larger flush valves to deliver strong flushing power. The Power Flush system in some models uses increased water volume and pressure to create a forceful flush.
Mansfield toilets primarily use Pressure-Assist and Gravity Flush technologies. Pressure-Assist toilets use compressed air to enhance flushing power, while Gravity Flush toilets rely on gravity to eliminate waste.
It’s worth noting that factors such as trapway design, bowl shape, and the plumbing system’s water pressure can affect the flushing performance. Additionally, specific models within each brand may have different flushing mechanisms and performance characteristics.
2. Water Efficiency
While American Standard and Mansfield offer water-efficient toilets, American Standard has a broader range of options. American Standard places a strong emphasis on water conservation and offers numerous water-efficient toilets.
Many American Standard toilet models are WaterSense certified, so they meet strict criteria for water efficiency. The brand’s toilets have a low-flow design, using 1.28 gallons per flush (gpf) or even less.
Also, they provide dual-flush options, allowing for further water savings by providing separate flushes for solid and liquid waste.
On the contrary, while Mansfield toilets offer water-efficient models, their range may not be as extensive as American Standard. Mansfield typically provides toilets with a standard 1.6 gpf, but they may have options with lower flow rates, such as 1.28 gpf.
3. Durability
American Standard has a reputation for manufacturing durable toilets. It uses high-quality materials and employs rigorous manufacturing processes to ensure long-lasting performance.
Its toilets are often constructed with vitreous china, a durable and robust material that is chip, stain, and scratch resistant. However, the durability of individual American Standard models may still vary.
Also, the thickness of the porcelain and the overall build quality should count when selecting. This is because weak porcelain can crack, causing issues like leaking; luckily, you can easily troubleshoot and fix American Standard problems.
Mansfield toilets are also generally considered durable. It produces toilets with solid construction and utilizes vitreous china as well, but durability may also vary based on the model and product line.
However, of the two brands, American Standard is more reputable for their durability.
4. Design Options
American Standard has an extensive selection of design options. The brand offers a variety of toilet styles, including one-piece and two-piece toilets, with different bowl shapes, heights, and finishes.
American Standard will likely have options that cater to your aesthetic preferences, like traditional, sleek, and contemporary designs. Additionally, it introduces new designs and innovations, allowing customers to pick from a broader range of styles.
Mansfield also offers a range of design options, but their selection is less extensive than American Standard. Nonetheless, it provides both one-piece and two-piece toilets with various configurations.
Mansfield toilets tend to have a more classic and traditional design aesthetic. However, it still offers various styles and finishes to suit different bathroom décors.
5. Easy Of Cleaning
American Standard toilets’ additional features, such as EverClean surfaces, one-piece designs, and concealed trapways, contribute to easier cleaning. However, Mansfield toilets can still offer hassle-free cleaning due to their smooth surfaces and simplified designs.
Many Mansfield toilets have smooth surfaces that are easy to wipe clean, reducing the chance of stains or residue clinging to the porcelain. They also have straightforward designs with fewer intricate contours, making them easier to clean without navigating around complex shapes or hard-to-reach areas.
Some American Standard toilets like the American Standard 2988101.020 (View on Amazon) have a concealed trapway. This trapway eliminates the nooks and crannies where dirt and debris accumulate making cleaning more straightforward.
On the other hand, EverClean surfaces inhibit stain- and odor-causing mildew, bacteria, and mold from growing. This coating helps keep the toilet cleaner longer and makes wiping away dirt and stains easier.
6. Warranty
Both brands provide warranties for their toilets ranging from a year to a lifetime. When evaluating warranties, pay attention to what’s covered and excluded.
Consider factors such as the warranty’s duration, limitations, and how to go about in order to file a warranty claim or seek repairs.
7. Price Range
American Standard toilets tend to be priced higher than Mansfield toilets. This brand is often positioned as a mid to high-end brand, offering a wide range of models with various features, designs, and technologies.
The advanced flushing systems, water-saving mechanisms, and innovative designs incorporated in these toilets contribute to the higher price point.
Mansfield toilets are more budget-friendly and positioned in the mid-range market. While they still offer reliable performance and a range of options, they have a more affordable price tag.
Note
Toilet pricing can vary based on the specific model, features, and finishes. Within each brand, there may be variations in pricing based on the product line and additional features offered.
So, when considering the cost of American Standard and Mansfield toilets, compare specific models.
Who Makes American Standard Toilets?
American Standard Brands, owned by LIXIL Corporation, manufactures American Standard toilets. American Standard, a leading plumbing fixture company in North America, was founded in 1929 and is headquartered in Piscataway, New Jersey.
It produces a wide range of plumbing products, including toilets, faucets, sinks, bathtubs, and other bathroom and kitchen fixtures. American Standard is known for its quality and innovative designs, with its toilets widely used in residential and commercial settings.
LIXIL Corporation, a global building materials and housing equipment company based in Japan acquired American Standard Brands in 2013.
LIXIL is a leading company in the housing and building industry, specializing in water and housing products, including sanitary ware, kitchen fixtures, windows, and doors. American Standard continues to operate as a subsidiary of LIXIL Corporation and remains a well-known brand in the plumbing fixture industry.
Who Makes Mansfield Toilets?
Mansfield Plumbing Products is the company that manufactures Mansfield toilets. Mansfield Plumbing Products is based in Perrysville, Ohio, and has produced plumbing fixtures since 1929.
The company specializes in manufacturing toilets, sinks, and other plumbing products. It is known for its focus on quality and innovation in the plumbing industry, and its toilets are widely used in residential and commercial applications.
Are American Standard Toilets Good Quality?
American Standard toilets are good quality. The brand is reputable and well-established in the plumbing industry, with a long history of manufacturing reliable and durable fixtures.
The brand is committed to innovation, performance, and customer satisfaction. Its toilets often feature solid construction, using high-quality materials such as vitreous china, known for its strength and durability.
Also, American Standard makes highly durable products, tested rigorously to ensure they meet industry standards and deliver long-lasting performance.
Additionally, these toilets have efficient flushing systems, water-saving technologies, and innovative features like the VorMax flushing system or dual-flush options. These features contribute to effective waste removal and water conservation, making them popular among homeowners.
Are Mansfield Toilets Any Good Quality?
Mansfield toilets are good quality. The manufacturer has been producing plumbing fixtures for many decades and has established a reputation for reliability and durability.
These toilets are known for their solid construction and use of high-quality materials, including vitreous china. They undergo testing and quality control processes to make sure they attain industry standards and give long-lasting performance.
Mansfield may not have the same level of brand recognition as some other toilet manufacturers. However, its toilets are widely used in commercial and residential settings.
These toilets are known for their reliable flushing mechanisms, effective waste removal, and overall functionality. They are also not susceptible to clogs, but Mansfield Toilet Troubleshooting Guide will come in handy should it get clogged or develop other problems.
Now that we’ve established that both brands are great,
Are American Standard Toilets Better Than Mansfield Toilets?
Generally, American Standard is a better brand, especially if you prioritize design variety and durability. It has a long history and a strong reputation for quality and innovation, thus manufacturing high-performing toilets with excellent flushing systems.
However, remember that the “better” brand depends on your needs, preferences, and budget.
Final Remarks on American Standard Vs Mansfield Toilets
On paper, American Standard is a better toilet brand than Mansfield. However, research and compare specific models from both brands, considering factors such as design, performance, price, and warranty. In addition, customer reviews and seeking professional advice can also help inform your decision.
Here’s another related topic